St. John's Law Review

The Antitrust Legacy of Thurman Arnold

By: Spencer Weber Waller

No one will ever know exactly why Franklin Roosevelt hired Thurman Arnold as head of the Antitrust Division of the Justice Department in 1938.  It may simply have been that head of the Antitrust Division was the first important administration job available when Arnold’s supporters and friends sought a full-time Washington position for him.  While the nomination proved to be an awkward and controversial choice, it was also an inspired choice.  For the next five years, Thurman Arnold revitalized antitrust law and enforcement and changed the entire focus of the New Deal from corporatist planning to competition as the fundamental economic policy of the Roosevelt administration.  Those who favor a consumer-friendly competitive economy owe him a debt that transcends the specific cases he brought and the doctrines he espoused.  This Article is a look at that legacy.

Full text version available for download in PDF format.