St. John's Law Review

Leveling the Playing Field: Helping Students Succeed by Helping Them Learn to Read as Expert Lawyers

By: Laurel Currie Oates

I agree with Professor Vernellia Randall that law schools have an obligation to admit a diverse student body. In addition, I agree with Professor Richard Delgato that law schools should not allow concerns over their U.S. News and World Report ranking to effect their decisions about whether to admit a student who shows great promise but does not have “high numbers.” However, it is not enough to admit a diverse group of students. Law schools also have an obligation to level the playing field, or at least the exam room floor, so that all of the students they admit can be successful both as law students and as attorneys.

This essay explores one way in which law schools can level the field. The essay builds upon an article that I wrote almost ten years ago about how students’ reading skills and beliefs about text affect their success in law school. It then talks about why, given recent studies showing a decrease in reading and articles showing differences in the way parents of color and white parents read to their children, teaching legal reading is even more important today than it was ten years ago. The final section provides suggestions for law schools to help their students develop their reading skills and calls for further research on the factors that affect student success.