Five Validating Factors of Academic Service-Learning

Academic Service-Learning at St. John’s University is generally defined as an academic program that involves students in some form of required community service and uses that activity as a means of understanding course concepts.  

In this conceptualization, community is interpreted to include not just neighborhoods but any group or institution with an organized project goal where profit is not the over-all mission but rather, where social justice and working towards the common good are the major goals or purpose of the venture.  That is, any student community service placement and/or project can be considered Academic Service-Learning provided that the student is not directly involved in a profit making activity.  In addition, Academic Service-Learning requires five validating factors.

These are:

  1. The community service must be included as part of an academic course offering.
  2. The community service must meet a real and existing need.
  3. The student does not receive any financial reward for performing the service.
  4. There must be reciprocity between the service site and the student where it is clearly  understood that the student becomes one of the beneficiaries of the actions performed. Thus, students must be afforded the experiential learning opportunity to practice, perform and/or observe theories and practical applications of the course content and/or of  their discipline.
  5. Some form of organized academic service-learning reflection must be included in the  course. Reflection is the mechanism that encourages students to link their service experience with course content, as well as the importance of service to others and the  importance of individual participation in the democratic process.

This definition can be further understood through the examination of the standard for Pure Service-Learning, one of the six models for Academic Service-Learning described by Heffernan and Cone (2001). 

The fundamentals of the Pure Academic Service-Learning model are:

  • Students are sent into the community to serve;
  • Students are prepared for active, responsible service;
  • This type of service is not lodged in any one discipline.

Thus, it can be observed that Academic Service-Learning is not a “program but rather an instructional strategy, a philosophy, and a process” (Bhaerman, Cordell and Gomez, 1998, p. 1).