Public School Reorganization Discussed at St. John’s University’s Fifth Annual Education Forum on Staten Island

May 01, 2007

Staten Island, N.Y. -

A crowd of more than 400 teachers, administrators and parents gathered on the Staten Island campus of St. John’s University for the Fifth Annual Education Forum, titled “Reflections on the Restructuring of New York City’s Public Schools” on April 30.

31 I.D.E.A.L. (Information Dealing with Education And Learning), a Staten Island coalition of parents, teachers, and school community activists, co-sponsored the event which featured several esteemed professionals who gathered to discuss the recent reorganization within the New York City Department of Education. 

Photo Gallery

Jerrold Ross, Ph.D., Dean of The School of Education at St. John’s University, moderated the forum which featured leaders in education including, Chris Cerf, Deputy Chancellor, Department of Education; Betsy Gotbaum, The New York Public Advocate; Robert Jackson, Chairman of the Education Committee of the NYC; Tim Johnson, Chairman of the Chancellor’s Parent Advisory Council; Ernest Logan, President of the Council of School Supervisors and Administrators and Randi Weingarten, President of the United Federation of Teachers. 

Opening Statement Excerpts
Chris Cerf
Robert Jackson
Betsy Gotbaum
Tim Johnson
Ernest Logan
Randi Weingarten

In addition, Joan McKeever-Thomas, Chairperson, 31 I.D.E.A.L. and Karina Costantino, New York City Public School Principal, both addressed the overflow crowd, which included Dennis Walcott, Deputy Mayor for Education and Community Development.

The lone representative of the Department of Education (DOE), Cerf attempted to explain the current reorganization plan of the department, but also acknowledged inadequacies and mistakes made by the administration in the past six years.

“We have a great deal of pride in the plan that’s underway and the progress that we are making . We also have real humility about both our shortcomings and the distance that is yet to travel,” Cerf said.

Cerf offered the “guiding principals” of the current reform, beginning with accountability. He added the importance of having qualified teachers in each classroom and the ability to distribute “our resources fairly, transparently and ethically,” as key elements toward the success of the plan.

Jackson mentioned the lack of involvement in the decision making process and stressed the importance of keeping parents, teachers and principals included, while also applauding the D.O.E. for “listening a lot more.” Gotbaum, the Public Advocate, reiterated the importance of parental involvement and announced that she was “dedicating my next 2 ½ years to being there for the parents…and to try to work with all the organizations to make sure that the parents have a seat at the table.”

Speaking as a parent, Johnson was a bit more critical of the current administration in his comments, but also clearly listed what he wanted for parents and for the administration in order to move forward.  

“We need outstanding principals who are seasoned educational leaders, qualified and dedicated teaching professionals in our classrooms, engaged students…and parents who are empowered, consulted and respected,” he demanded.

Logan spoke of how his council has “pushed wholeheartedly for a change.”  He blamed the D.O.E. for not making students critical thinkers, instead merely grooming them to “know how to take a test.” 

Weingarten addressed several inadequacies she sees within the system before Dr. Ross opened the floor to questions.

Concerned Staten Island residents and teachers were given well over an hour to ask questions, most of which were directed to Cerf. The panelists patiently answered each question, and the give and take of constructive criticism was shared by all in attendance. 

For more information, please contact Elizabeth Reilly, Assistant Director of Media Relations at St. John’s by calling (718) 990-5789, or e-mail reillye@stjohns.edu. For additional news about St. John’s University, please visit www.stjohns.edu/news